IRS Must Refund Penalties Despite Tax Malpractice Recovery

In Ervin v. United States, No. 4:13-CV-00127-JHM (W.D. Ky. 2017), the court considered whether the government can withhold or set off a penalty refund owing to a taxpayer if the taxpayer has already recovered the amount in excess of the penalty from its tax advisor for malpractice. While the case does not create any new law, it is worth considering as clients do ask about this issue from time to time.

The facts in the case were as follows:

  • Ervin participated in a tax shelter was promoted by its tax advisor.
  • The IRS discovered and challenged the position and ultimately imposed the valuation misstatement penalty.
  • Ervin sued his tax advisor and received a sizeable settlement.
  • In addition, Ervin filed a refund claim for, paid, and litigated the penalty. The jury determined that Ervin qualified for reasonable cause for the penalty, presumably based on reliance on a tax advisor, and that no penalty was due.
  • The government refused to refund the amount Ervin paid for the penalty. In court, the government argued that it did not have to refund Ervin’s penalty payment as “a refund will result in a windfall and double recovery since the Plaintiffs have already received a large settlement from their tax advisors.”

The court had to answer the question as to whether the government could keep a tax refund that a jury had determined was due and owing to the taxpayer based on the idea that the taxpayer had already received compensation in excess of the penalty.

An affirmative answer would make pursuing tax refund claims in court somewhat meaningless if they could be disregarded by the government. It would also raise the question as to whether taxpayers could simply ignore the jury’s findings. Naturally, the answer is that the jury’s findings cannot be ignored.

The court did not have to spend a lot of time writing its opinion in this case. It noted that the government did not cite “a single instance in which a court has excused the government’s obligation to repay the improperly assessed and collected tax in a refund suit.” It simply noted that the tax refund was due and the government had to pay it to the taxpayer.

So the answer to the question in the case is, “no,” the government cannot keep a tax refund that it was ordered to pay back to a taxpayer, even though the taxpayer had already received an award in excess of the penalty amount from its tax advisor.

Call Now, We Can Help!


(713) 909-4906

Do you have a tax dispute, under audit by the IRS or state tax authorities, or just have a tax question? We want to hear from you. Call today for a free, confidential, consultation. If you are pressed for time, you can also use the contact form below to reach out to us.

Our Recent Reviews

Grga Brolih
Grga Brolih
09:20 24 Apr 17
I was a bit hesitant at first because I had not really done any research, just my friend told me about Houston Tax Attorney. Anyway i decided to give them a try and I was really impressed and pleased with the outcome of my experience. They were always very pleasant and professional and made me feel free from my tax issues. Good job!
Brown Jones
Brown Jones
08:54 10 Jun 17
Houston Tax Attorney has given me my life back. I was unable to pay my payroll taxes and in combination with the penalties attached to those taxes, my debt had begun to snowball. Houston Tax Attorney genuinely cares about their clients; they helped me throughout the process. I am extremely grateful to them.
Sandra Camacho
Sandra Camacho
03:47 27 May 17
I had a tax problem and needed help, so I went to Houston Tax Attorney. Love the team, they were so organized and communicated. Good work was done!
Turman Villanueva
Turman Villanueva
12:20 21 Apr 17
Dealing with Houston Tax Attorney was simple from the beginning to the end. Every person I spoke to was knowledgeable and helpful. I was guided in all aspects of the process and given the best advice regarding my tax condition. I have been given a second chance with the IRS. Thank you.
Bill Moore
Bill Moore
07:05 02 Jun 17
I want to Thank Houston Tax Attorney team. They took care of my IRS issues with great professionalism. No more sleepless nights. Thank you Guys!
Sharon G. Velasco
Sharon G. Velasco
08:31 24 Jun 17
I had some big tax issues and I was unable to handle it alone. Houston Tax Attorney helped me to settle all my tax problems. They were there all the way. I respect their professionalism and appreciate their commitment to their clients.
See All Reviews