Partnership Tax Return Cannot be Corrected by Amended Tax Return

Partnership Tax Return Cannot be Corrected by Amended Tax Return

In U.S. v. Stewart, No. 15-20596, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that the taxpayer was not entitled to a tax refund that was based on a corrected Schedule K-1 received from a partnership the taxpayer owned. The question on appeal was whether a partnership tax return can be corrected by filing an amended tax return.

Facts & Procedural History

The partnership filed a tax return to report a $20 million ordinary gain. It issued Schedules K-1 to the partners reflecting their distributive share of the $20 million ordinary gain.

Two years later, the partnership filed an amended tax return and issued corrected Schedules K-1 reflecting a $20 million capital gain, rather than an ordinary gain. The partners filed amended tax returns accordingly.

The IRS issued refunds to the partner involved in this case and denied the refund for another partner. In denying the refund for the other partner, the IRS realized that it issued the refunds to the partner involved in this case in error. The IRS brought suit to recoup the erroneous refund. The district court concluded that the gain was capital in nature and that the refund was properly issued. The IRS appealed the decision to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.

The Administrative Adjustment Request

The issue for the appeals court was whether the refunds were properly issued. The IRS argued that they were not properly issued, as neither the partnership nor the partners filed an Administrative Adjustment Request (“AAR”) under I.R.C. § 6227 on a Form 8082. Neither the partnership nor the taxpayer in this case filed the Form 8082. Instead, they merely filed amended tax returns. So the appeals court agreed with the IRS.

Substantial Compliance With AAR Requirements

The court then considered substantial compliance. In a prior case, the Fifth Circuit had said that substantial compliance with the AAR requirements is sufficient. According to the court, this would include a detailed statement on the amended tax return explaining why the return was being amended. The IRS has made it clear that it expects detailed explanations for AARs. This is evident in the Form 8082 itself. The Form 8082 is a two page form that provides a page and a half of blank lines for taxpayers to write in their explanation. Compare this to the Form 1040X, which provides a quarter page blank to write in an explanation.

The court also noted that substantial compliance also requires the taxpayers send the amended returns to the appropriate IRS service center for AARs. According to the instructions for the Form 8082, when filed after the original due date for the partnership return, the partner is to mail a copy in with their amended tax return and to the IRS service center where the partnership files its partnership tax return.

The taxpayer did not do either of these things in the current case. The amended tax returns did not contain the level of detail required for an AAR and they were not mailed to the correct IRS service center. So the court concluded that the refunds were not properly issued.

Call Now, We Can Help!

 

(713) 909-4906

Do you have a tax dispute, under audit by the IRS or state tax authorities, or just have a tax question? We want to hear from you. Call today for a free, confidential, consultation. If you are pressed for time, you can also use the contact form below to reach out to us.

Our Recent Reviews

Grga Brolih
Grga Brolih
09:20 24 Apr 17
I was a bit hesitant at first because I had not really done any research, just my friend told me about Houston Tax Attorney. Anyway i decided to give them a try and I was really impressed and pleased with the outcome of my experience. They were always very pleasant and professional and made me feel free from my tax issues. Good job!
Brown Jones
Brown Jones
08:54 10 Jun 17
Houston Tax Attorney has given me my life back. I was unable to pay my payroll taxes and in combination with the penalties attached to those taxes, my debt had begun to snowball. Houston Tax Attorney genuinely cares about their clients; they helped me throughout the process. I am extremely grateful to them.
Sandra Camacho
Sandra Camacho
03:47 27 May 17
I had a tax problem and needed help, so I went to Houston Tax Attorney. Love the team, they were so organized and communicated. Good work was done!
Turman Villanueva
Turman Villanueva
12:20 21 Apr 17
Dealing with Houston Tax Attorney was simple from the beginning to the end. Every person I spoke to was knowledgeable and helpful. I was guided in all aspects of the process and given the best advice regarding my tax condition. I have been given a second chance with the IRS. Thank you.
Bill Moore
Bill Moore
07:05 02 Jun 17
I want to Thank Houston Tax Attorney team. They took care of my IRS issues with great professionalism. No more sleepless nights. Thank you Guys!
Sharon G. Velasco
Sharon G. Velasco
08:31 24 Jun 17
I had some big tax issues and I was unable to handle it alone. Houston Tax Attorney helped me to settle all my tax problems. They were there all the way. I respect their professionalism and appreciate their commitment to their clients.
See All Reviews